Lifestyle

The Italian Sea Group's EUR 220 Million Rescue: What It Means for Owners With a Yacht in Build

A surveyor in a high-visibility vest holds a tablet and a folder of documents beneath the unpainted metal hull of a part-built superyacht in a daylight-filled construction hall, with scaffolding around the hull and a shipyard worker nearby.

The Italian Sea Group, the builder of Admiral, Perini Navi and Tecnomar yachts, has chosen its buyer. On 16 November the company said a bidding round run under the directions of the Court of Florence had selected SRI Global Limited's offer of EUR 220 million for the whole business. Its rescue plan, filed on 2 November, pays unsecured creditors about 10 cents on the euro and shareholders nothing, according to Il Sole 24 Ore. Borsa Italiana suspended the shares on 3 November.

For anyone with a yacht in build, a warranty claim or money paid to the yard, the sale raises a narrower question: who finishes the boat, and who stands behind what was paid. The reports published so far do not answer it.

The deal is not done

SRI, owned by Giulio Gallazzi and Bernardo Vacchi, has won the auction but has not signed anything yet. The company says its board meets on 23 November to ask the court for permission to sign a lease of the business and a preliminary sale agreement with SRI. That request depends on three things: evidence that SRI actually has the funds it has committed, including its business plan; approvals from the authorities, including the port authorities; and agreements with the trade unions.

Forbes Italia reports that Azimut Benetti, the other bidder for the whole group, took part in the auction but did not raise its offer. The court did not admit a EUR 250 million offer from Hong Kong-based Tisg Asia Investment Holding, which it judged inadmissible, and a proposal from Palumbo was also not accepted. SuperYacht24 puts SRI's total proposal at EUR 260 million: EUR 220 million for the assets and EUR 40 million in liquidity to restart production. The bids from Polo Nautico Carrara (linked to Sanlorenzo), Baglietto and Fincantieri covered only the La Spezia operations or site.

Under the plan, the buyer leases the business first and completes the purchase later. The timetable reported before the auction put the lease in the first week of December; it now waits on the court's permission and the conditions above. Once the court approves the plan, The Italian Sea Group goes into liquidation and stops running the yards itself.

Why the recovery is so low

Net equity stood at negative EUR 422.7 million on 31 August, after a loss of EUR 46.1 million in the first eight months of the year, Milano Finanza reports. Marine Industry News gives EUR 270.04 million of overdue liabilities at 31 July, including EUR 85.7 million owed to suppliers, and current liabilities of EUR 505.3 million against current assets of EUR 42.7 million at 30 June.

The 10 percent may not be the whole recovery. PressMare reports that the company's compensation and restitution claims would pass to creditors through a trust or a similar vehicle, separately from the sale price, so what creditors finally receive would also depend on how those actions end.

Where owners have stood so far

The court has moved on owners more than once. According to Reuters, carried by Baird Maritime on 1 July, a Florence court had partly lifted protective measures for five clients, letting them use their contract rights, including termination. PressMare reported on 7 July that the measures then confirmed stopped owners from ending contracts over an alleged yard default and from enforcing the guarantees issued to them.

Marine Industry News then reported a further partial revocation of the protection against owners in late July, and that in early August the court refused the company's request to suspend ongoing construction contracts. Its reading was that owners may be able to walk away under their contract terms in some cases.

No report AVNET has read gives the number of yachts in build, the customer deposits held, how owners rank among creditors, what protection applies to them now that a buyer has been chosen, or whether existing build contracts pass to the buyer.

What to put to a lawyer

The legal points below come from published commentary on shipyard failures in general, not from advice on this case.

  • The refund guarantee. Jay Tooker of HFW told Superyacht Investor in 2023 that only two forms of security really work: a guarantee from a bank or creditworthy third party refunding everything paid, or title passing during construction. Who issued yours, can it be enforced today, and when does it expire? Bob Allen of Robert Allen Law warned in the same piece that bank guarantees have expiry periods. Linda Roxburgh of Wikborg Rein, writing in SuperyachtNews in 2024, noted that a guarantee from a parent in the same group may fail with the yard.
  • Title to the hull. Roxburgh wrote that early title transfer, where local law allows it, can keep a part-built yacht out of the failed yard's estate. Tooker said ownership during construction is governed by local law. Does your contract pass title, and was it registered as that law requires? Allen cautioned that retrieving a boat can involve "astounding" legal fees.
  • Your creditor class. The 10 percent applies to unsecured claims. Which class would a deposit claim or a warranty claim fall into under this plan?
  • Who holds the contract next. In an asset deal with a lease, does your build contract follow the business, and on what terms? Who answers warranty claims on a delivered yacht once the old company is in liquidation?
  • Whether leaving helps. Roxburgh wrote that a moratorium can pause termination rights once formal proceedings begin, so the current position of your own contract matters. An owner who leaves also needs another route to a yacht. AVNET has reported that the largest new superyacht contract announced this year delivers in May 2032, and the alternative is the preowned market.

The workforce is part of the answer

A finished yacht needs the people who were building it. Marine Industry News reported that a regional crisis meeting was set for September on a solidarity agreement covering about 500 employees. After the filing, TG Regione reported that Fim-Cisl, Uilm and the company's union representatives want every job at Marina di Carrara reabsorbed and reject any break-up of the group.

The next dates: the board meeting on 23 November, the court's decision on the lease and the preliminary sale after that, and the delayed half-year accounts on 10 December. Until the court gives its permission and SRI shows its funds, EUR 220 million is the winning bid, not a completed sale.

Stay Ahead With AVNET

Join thousands of industry professionals who trust AVNET to keep them informed and ahead in the fast-paced world of aviation, all in One Minute a Week newsletter.

Contact Us